Nostalgic Candy

Clear all
Old Fashioned Candy Cigarette's

Old Fashioned Candy Cigarette's

$9.99 - $199.99
Rock Candy - All Colors

Rock Candy - All Colors

$14.99 - $39.99
+7
Candy Straws - All Colors

Candy Straws - All Colors

$12.99
$12.99 reg.
+2
Lemonheads Wrapped

Lemonheads Wrapped

$9.99 - $129.99
Frooties - All Colors
8 Colors Available

Frooties - All Colors

$7.99 - $139.99
+5
Slo Poke Bite Size Caramel Candy

Slo Poke Bite Size Caramel Candy

$9.99 - $29.99
Swedish Fish Gummies

Swedish Fish Gummies

$7.99 - $139.99
Swirly Pop - All Colors
8 Colors Available

Swirly Pop - All Colors

$9.99 - $179.99
+4
Nostalgic Tootsie Roll Midgees

Nostalgic Tootsie Roll Midgees

$7.99 - $129.99
Sour Patch Kids

Sour Patch Kids

$7.99 - $149.99
Chocolate Coins - All Colors
8 Colors Available

Chocolate Coins - All Colors

$9.99 - $89.99
+6
Black Cow Bite Size Chocolate Caramel Candy

Black Cow Bite Size Chocolate Caramel Candy

$11.99 - $104.99
Old Fashioned Chick-O-Stick Bites

Old Fashioned Chick-O-Stick Bites

$9.99 - $34.99
Mini Red Swedish Fish

Mini Red Swedish Fish

$7.99 - $139.99
Retro Root Beer Barrels

Retro Root Beer Barrels

$6.99 - $179.99
100 Grand by Nestle 10oz Bag

100 Grand by Nestle 10oz Bag

$7.99 - $69.99
Charleston Chew Vanilla Snack Size Bars

Charleston Chew Vanilla Snack Size Bars

$14.99 - $219.99
Red Swedish Fish

Red Swedish Fish

$7.99 - $139.99
Vanilla Caramel Square

Vanilla Caramel Square

$9.99 - $149.99
Swedish Fish - Assorted Colors

Swedish Fish - Assorted Colors

$7.99 - $139.99
Half Dollar Chocolate Gold Coins

Half Dollar Chocolate Gold Coins

$29.99 - $249.99
Frooties Green Apple

Frooties Green Apple

$7.99 - $139.99
Frooties Watermelon

Frooties Watermelon

$7.99 - $139.99
Caramel Apple Pops

Caramel Apple Pops

$14.99 - $139.99
Lifesavers 5 Flavor Hard Candy Rolls 20ct

Lifesavers 5 Flavor Hard Candy Rolls 20ct

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Frooties Fruit Punch

Frooties Fruit Punch

$7.99 - $139.99
Frooties Pineapple

Frooties Pineapple

$7.99 - $139.99
Lifesavers 5 Flavor Hard Candy - 50oz Bag

Lifesavers 5 Flavor Hard Candy - 50oz Bag

$19.99
$19.99 reg.
Frooties Strawberry Lemonade

Frooties Strawberry Lemonade

$7.99 - $139.99
Frooties Blue Raspberry

Frooties Blue Raspberry

$7.99 - $139.99
Red and Blue Frooties

Red and Blue Frooties

$12.99 - $25.98
Starburst Original Fruit Chews

Starburst Original Fruit Chews

$9.99 - $119.99
Frooties Mango

Frooties Mango

$7.99 - $139.99
Frooties Grape

Frooties Grape

$7.99 - $139.99
Old Fashioned Smarties

Old Fashioned Smarties

$6.99 - $169.99
Blue Razz Pop Rocks - 24ct Box

Blue Razz Pop Rocks - 24ct Box

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Original Bazooka Bubble Gum

Original Bazooka Bubble Gum

$24.99 - $129.99
Candy Sticks 80ct - All colors

Candy Sticks 80ct - All colors

$19.99
$19.99 reg.
+7
Childs Play Candy - 3.25 lb

Childs Play Candy - 3.25 lb

$14.99
$14.99 reg.
Tootsie Roll Pops - 39lb Case

Tootsie Roll Pops - 39lb Case

$179.99
$179.99 reg.
Malt Balls Jumbo

Malt Balls Jumbo

$21.99 - $64.99
Mini Dark Chocolate Nonpareils

Mini Dark Chocolate Nonpareils

$24.99 - $89.99
Skittles Original

Skittles Original

$17.99 - $99.99
Nestle Crunch Bars 1.55oz Bar (36ct Box)

Nestle Crunch Bars 1.55oz Bar (36ct Box)

$49.99
$49.99 reg.
Starburst All Pink Fruit Chews

Starburst All Pink Fruit Chews

$9.99 - $39.99
Green Sour Apple Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

Green Sour Apple Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Purple Grape Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

Purple Grape Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Wild Blue Raspberry Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

Wild Blue Raspberry Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Yellow Banana Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

Yellow Banana Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Old Fashioned Smarties

Old Fashioned Smarties

$6.99 - $169.99
Blue Razz Pop Rocks - 24ct Box

Blue Razz Pop Rocks - 24ct Box

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Original Bazooka Bubble Gum

Original Bazooka Bubble Gum

$24.99 - $129.99
Candy Sticks 80ct - All colors

Candy Sticks 80ct - All colors

$19.99
$19.99 reg.
+7
Childs Play Candy - 3.25 lb

Childs Play Candy - 3.25 lb

$14.99
$14.99 reg.
Tootsie Roll Pops - 39lb Case

Tootsie Roll Pops - 39lb Case

$179.99
$179.99 reg.
Malt Balls Jumbo

Malt Balls Jumbo

$21.99 - $64.99
Mini Dark Chocolate Nonpareils

Mini Dark Chocolate Nonpareils

$24.99 - $89.99
Skittles Original

Skittles Original

$17.99 - $99.99
Nestle Crunch Bars 1.55oz Bar (36ct Box)

Nestle Crunch Bars 1.55oz Bar (36ct Box)

$49.99
$49.99 reg.
Starburst All Pink Fruit Chews

Starburst All Pink Fruit Chews

$9.99 - $39.99
Green Sour Apple Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

Green Sour Apple Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Purple Grape Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

Purple Grape Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Wild Blue Raspberry Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

Wild Blue Raspberry Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

$24.99
$24.99 reg.
Yellow Banana Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

Yellow Banana Laffy Taffy - 145ct Tub

$24.99
$24.99 reg.