SHOP TOP FIRST BIRTHDAY ITEMS

BULK CANDY

BULK CANDY

CHOCOLATE BARS

CHOCOLATE BARS

MINIS & KISSES

MINIS & KISSES

CANDY FAVORS

CANDY FAVORS

First Birthday

Clear all
Personalized 1st Birthday Party Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar

Personalized 1st Birthday Party Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar

$2.99
$2.99 reg.
+6
Personalized First Birthday Train Hershey's Kisses

Personalized First Birthday Train Hershey's Kisses

$0.37
$0.37 reg.
Personalized Birthday Embossed Happy birthday Chocolate Bar Minnie Mouse Theme

Personalized Birthday Embossed Happy birthday Chocolate Bar Minnie Mouse Theme

$2.19
$2.19 reg. $2.74
Birthday Personalized Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy Mickey Mouse

Birthday Personalized Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy Mickey Mouse

$37.99 - $79.99
Personalized Birthday Unicorn Hershey's Miniatures

Personalized Birthday Unicorn Hershey's Miniatures

$0.79 - $0.99
Birthday Personalized Chocolate Bar Wrappers Flowers & Photo
WRAPPERS ONLY

Birthday Personalized Chocolate Bar Wrappers Flowers & Photo

$0.79 - $0.89
+10
Birthday Personalized Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar Monogram Circle Photo

Birthday Personalized Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar Monogram Circle Photo

$2.99 - $3.14
+6
Birthday 1.25" Sticker Mickey Mouse (48 Stickers)
Stickers Only

Birthday 1.25" Sticker Mickey Mouse (48 Stickers)

$6.99
$6.99 reg.
Birthday Personalized Small Light Pink Swirly Pop Butterfly 1st Birthday (24 Pack)

Birthday Personalized Small Light Pink Swirly Pop Butterfly 1st Birthday (24 Pack)

$14.99
$14.99 reg.
Birthday Personalized Paint Can Lion 1st Birthday (25 Pack)

Birthday Personalized Paint Can Lion 1st Birthday (25 Pack)

$39.75
$39.75 reg.
Personalized Birthday Whimsical Unicorn Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar & Wrapper

Personalized Birthday Whimsical Unicorn Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar & Wrapper

$2.19 - $3.14
Personalized First Birthday Train 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)
Stickers Only

Personalized First Birthday Train 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)

$6.99
$6.99 reg.
Personalized Birthday Embossed Happy birthday Chocolate Bar Photo Cupcake 1st

Personalized Birthday Embossed Happy birthday Chocolate Bar Photo Cupcake 1st

$2.19
$2.19 reg. $2.74
Birthday Personalized Hershey's Miniatures Wrappers Mickey Mouse
Wrappers Only

Birthday Personalized Hershey's Miniatures Wrappers Mickey Mouse

$7.99
$7.99 reg.
Personalized 1st Birthday Party Chocolate Bar Wrappers
WRAPPERS ONLY

Personalized 1st Birthday Party Chocolate Bar Wrappers

$0.79 - $0.89
+7
Birthday Personalized Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar Photo Cupcake 1st

Birthday Personalized Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar Photo Cupcake 1st

$2.19 - $2.99
Personalized Birthday Circus Embossed Happy Birthday Chocolate Bar

Personalized Birthday Circus Embossed Happy Birthday Chocolate Bar

$2.19
$2.19 reg. $2.74
Birthday Personalized Chocolate Bar Wrappers Monogram Circle Photo
WRAPPERS ONLY

Birthday Personalized Chocolate Bar Wrappers Monogram Circle Photo

$5.99 - $6.59
+6
Personalized Birthday Circus Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

Personalized Birthday Circus Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

$37.99 - $79.99
Personalized Birthday Elephant 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)
Stickers Only

Personalized Birthday Elephant 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)

$6.99
$6.99 reg.
Birthday Personalized Chocolate Bar Wrappers Minnie Mouse Theme
WRAPPERS ONLY

Birthday Personalized Chocolate Bar Wrappers Minnie Mouse Theme

$5.99 - $6.59
Personalized Birthday Farmhouse Miniatures Wrappers
Wrappers Only

Personalized Birthday Farmhouse Miniatures Wrappers

$7.99
$7.99 reg.
Personalized Birthday Circus Chocolate Bar Wrappers
WRAPPERS ONLY

Personalized Birthday Circus Chocolate Bar Wrappers

$5.99 - $6.59
Personalized Birthday Farmhouse York Peppermint Patties - pack of 70

Personalized Birthday Farmhouse York Peppermint Patties - pack of 70

$39.99
$39.99 reg.
Birthday Personalized Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar Minnie Mouse Theme

Birthday Personalized Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar Minnie Mouse Theme

$2.19 - $3.14
Personalized Birthday Butterfly Miniatures Wrappers
Wrappers Only

Personalized Birthday Butterfly Miniatures Wrappers

$7.99
$7.99 reg.
All Aboard First Birthday Personalized Rectangular Stickers (18 Stickers)

All Aboard First Birthday Personalized Rectangular Stickers (18 Stickers)

$8.99
$8.99 reg.
Personalized Birthday Circus Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar & Wrapper

Personalized Birthday Circus Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar & Wrapper

$2.19 - $3.14
Birthday Personalized Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar Mickey Mouse

Birthday Personalized Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar Mickey Mouse

$2.19 - $3.14
Personalized Birthday Elephant 3/4" Sticker (108 Stickers)
Stickers Only

Personalized Birthday Elephant 3/4" Sticker (108 Stickers)

$7.99
$7.99 reg.
Personalized Birthday Butterfly Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

Personalized Birthday Butterfly Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

$37.99 - $79.99
Birthday Personalized Chocolate Bar Wrappers Mickey Mouse
WRAPPERS ONLY

Birthday Personalized Chocolate Bar Wrappers Mickey Mouse

$5.99 - $6.59
Personalized Birthday Farmhouse Chocolate Bar Wrappers
WRAPPERS ONLY

Personalized Birthday Farmhouse Chocolate Bar Wrappers

$5.99 - $6.59
Personalized Birthday Circus Hershey's Kisses

Personalized Birthday Circus Hershey's Kisses

$0.37
$0.37 reg.
Personalized Birthday Embossed Happy birthday Chocolate Bar Mickey Mouse

Personalized Birthday Embossed Happy birthday Chocolate Bar Mickey Mouse

$2.19
$2.19 reg. $2.74
Personalized Birthday Farmhouse Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

Personalized Birthday Farmhouse Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

$37.99 - $79.99
Personalized Birthday Circus 3/4" Sticker (108 Stickers)
Stickers Only

Personalized Birthday Circus 3/4" Sticker (108 Stickers)

$7.99
$7.99 reg.
Personalized Birthday Farmhouse Life Savers Mints

Personalized Birthday Farmhouse Life Savers Mints

$0.29
$0.29 reg.
Personalized First Birthday Train Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

Personalized First Birthday Train Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

$37.99 - $79.99
Personalized Birthday Farmhouse 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)
Stickers Only

Personalized Birthday Farmhouse 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)

$6.99
$6.99 reg.
Personalized First Birthday Train Chocolate Bar Wrappers
WRAPPERS ONLY

Personalized First Birthday Train Chocolate Bar Wrappers

$5.99 - $6.59
Personalized Birthday Lion Chocolate Bar Wrappers
WRAPPERS ONLY

Personalized Birthday Lion Chocolate Bar Wrappers

$5.99 - $6.59
Personalized Birthday Circus 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)
Stickers Only

Personalized Birthday Circus 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)

$6.99
$6.99 reg.
Personalized Birthday Circus Miniatures Wrappers
Wrappers Only

Personalized Birthday Circus Miniatures Wrappers

$7.99
$7.99 reg.
Personalized Birthday Elephant Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

Personalized Birthday Elephant Life Savers 5 Flavor Hard Candy

$37.99 - $79.99
Personalized Birthday Elephant Hershey's Kisses

Personalized Birthday Elephant Hershey's Kisses

$0.37
$0.37 reg.
Personalized Birthday Butterfly 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)
Stickers Only

Personalized Birthday Butterfly 1.25" Stickers (48 Stickers)

$6.99
$6.99 reg.
Personalized Birthday Butterfly Chocolate Bar Wrappers
WRAPPERS ONLY

Personalized Birthday Butterfly Chocolate Bar Wrappers

$5.99 - $6.59
Sweet First Birthday Girl Personalized 2" Stickers (20 Stickers)

Sweet First Birthday Girl Personalized 2" Stickers (20 Stickers)

$7.99
$7.99 reg.
Sweet First Birthday Girl Personalized Rectangular Stickers (18 Stickers)

Sweet First Birthday Girl Personalized Rectangular Stickers (18 Stickers)

$8.99
$8.99 reg.